SECHUK JURY 2016 - COMMENTS & SCORES FOR: AUSTRIA
TO THE LEADERBOARD / MEET THE JURY
|
|
|
LOIN D'ICI
ZOË |
|
SECHUK JURY Rating 223.5/320 (69.8%) |
||
|
INTERNATIONAL JURY |
|
INT JURY TOTAL 105.5 |
||||
|
Amar |
|
Very interesting
choice by |
5 |
|||
|
Benedek |
|
What
was |
5 |
|||
|
Christos |
|
A
pleasant time with the original choice of French verse. If it was |
7 |
|||
|
Daria |
|
Very mediocre song, but “sweet freakness” makes it unforgettable. I hope she will keep those giant mushrooms as a backdrop. However it’s not that kind of freak songs that usually qualify to the final. |
7 |
|||
|
Douwe |
|
The first Austrian entry to be sung entirely in French, this is fresh, sweet, simple and cute but I am not sure that it will be strong enough to set the scoreboard on fire. There are similarities here with Anna Rossinelli's 'In Love For A While' and it could be good to stick with the gorgeous graphics, again reminiscent to Anna in 2011.If ZOË makes the final she will gather a few points here and there but not a winner. |
6 |
|||
|
Elena |
|
Very cute song, but apparently the singer can't handle it as the high note disappears every time. I like that she sings in French and the stenography is really cool, but it gets boring. |
4 |
|||
|
Frederico |
|
I
think this is a great choice for |
8.5 |
|||
|
José |
|
A great background, a fresh song and a very charismatic singer is the whole merit of this song, that is now the 7th wonder, but still very nice one |
8.5 |
|||
|
Mark L |
|
A pleasant little
ditty but I am concerned that it may not stand out from the rest in |
6 |
|||
|
Melissa |
|
I'm not really a fan of this - it's just a little sickly-sweet for my liking. I'm actually surprised it managed to win a national final because it's not a song that will have viewers at home running for their phones to cast votes for it. |
5.5 |
|||
|
Octavio |
|
She has a sweet voice and the rhythm is great. Cute song, pretty girl but melody too repetitive. I think it needs a different staging and she needs a different outfit. it's just sent many years too late. |
6 |
|||
|
Paul C |
|
A very nice and sweet
entry from |
8 |
|||
|
Pia |
|
Now we´re talking ....good old fashioned ESC -song ! The flowergirl gets 9 points from me . Fine song , fine melody ! |
9 |
|||
|
Roberto |
|
A song in French for |
6 |
|||
|
|
|
I
think |
7 |
|||
|
Samantha |
|
Super-sweet, this sounds like a modernized version of something I'd find on the Amelie soundtrack. I worry it might not have a massive impact on the scoreboard, since it is a bit subtle, but it's pleasant! |
7 |
|||
|
|
|
JURY TOTAL 118 |
||||
|
Andrew C |
|
Yes, it is more than a little old fashioned and yes it does have more than a passing resemblance to Joe le Taxi but I love it. Was ready to give up after the early performances and so happy it won against two other songs more favoured by the jury! |
8 |
|||
|
Andrew G |
|
OK Austria is now my best so far, i liked it instantly i heard it, and this is why i like eurovision because of songs like this. I really like the fact that shes is singing in french, and this is how it`s supposed to be, i really hope it dose well, it`s a nice song and shes got a nice voice, i look forward to seeing this on the night. |
10 |
|||
|
Daniel |
|
I
loved Zoë last year when she sang Quel Filou and I love her this year
too. Loin D'ici is a lovely song and she performs it well. Hopefully |
7 |
|||
|
Danny |
|
A song in French? For |
9 |
|||
|
David B |
|
Now every contest needs something that is jolly and bordering on the twee. Dear old Zoe is channelling her inner Sophie Carle in this lovely bit of froth. Maybe 2016's guilty pleasure! |
8 |
|||
|
David E |
|
This
is quirky, saccharin and rather jolly. I think it'll do well, and
see |
7.5 |
|||
|
Dean |
|
A
fabulously old fashioned Eurovision entry which swept away all the modern
stuff in the national final. I love this charmingly poppy and innocent
song. Hope it does well in |
8.5 |
|||
|
Eddie |
|
Surprising but i really like it. Sounds like a recent French pop hit but she sells it really well. Love the walk way.and the simplicity of the performance. In an era of big productions, this stands out. a finalist for me. |
7 |
|||
|
|
|
I’m taken back to 1984 and Sophie Carle (Lux) – a sweet girl singing a French ditty in the style of Vanessa Paradis. It’s nice, but maybe too light and I can’t see it setting the scoreboard alight. |
5.5 |
|||
|
Joe |
|
Now here is a
surprise. |
8.5 |
|||
|
Mark M |
|
Not really my thing - really sickly sweet and something you would have heard in an early 90s contest. She's got a nice voice but something about her irritates me. |
3.5 |
|||
|
Martin |
|
An Austrian singing an up-tempo French chanson, sounding like Vanessa Paradis? Not the best French language song I've ever heard but a pleasant surprise nevertheless, given the vocal excellence and enthusiastic performance of ZOË. The childlike sound, fairytale backdrop and bridal gown did make it all very saccharine however. |
7 |
|||
|
Matt |
|
Taking away the unfortunate title and it's English
connotation, this isn't too bad and one of the best picked thus far.
That said, it's not saying too much as while enjoyable, the last minute of
so sounds like a stuck record. Nice voice and stage pressence
though. |
7 |
|||
|
Nico |
|
Very sweet, perhaps
overly so. By the end of the song I feel a bit of toothache coming on. My
only issue is that it starts out rather promising, but doesn't quite build
enough for any kind of crescendo. Good for |
6.5 |
|||
|
Sally-Ann |
|
I love this Vanessa
Paradis-style pop song. It's lilting melody sounds SO much better in
French than it would've done in German! A good live performance will give |
8 |
|||
|
Tristán |
|
Far less annoying than her attempt last year ("Quel filou") and overall a far stronger song. I would have far preferred Bella Wagner, Elly V or Sankil Jones but overall this is a sweet song that would suit Vanessa Paradis equally well. Should certainly qualify for the final. |
7 |
|||